Self-Defined Human
Self-Defined Human
#45 - Piano NERDS, Bach & Wrong Notes (with guest Dr. David Servias)
/

I invited Dr. David Servias to have a conversation with me about the Bach Toccata & Fugue fiasco. We discuss the history of the piece, why the NERDS can’t process one out-of-place note, and how I’m dealing with hate on my YouTube channel.

For the backstory, watch the original video (and read the comments 🤦‍♂️)

Thanks for listening.

If you have not taken my course Learn Piano in 5 Days yet, that would be a good starting place for you. You can access it for $5.00 here: https://michaelkorman.com/learn-piano-in-5-days/

Or, if you’d like to work with me 1-1 (online), you can sign up for the Intensive Song Study: https://michaelkorman.com/intensive-song-study/

Both of these are for beginners. No experience needed. Just willingness to try new things.

Timeline:

00:00:00 – I posted a cute little piano tutorial and the music theory NERDS freaked out.

00:02:39 – Bringing Dr. Servias on to help settle the debate.

00:04:22 – The list of accusations against me. Responding “appropriately.” Two kinds of nerds.

00:05:57 – David explains the controversy. What’s the Toccata and Fugue? What did I play? What were they expecting me to play?

00:11:32 – Does any of this matter? What would Bach have said? Would you have to follow his orders?

00:13:56 – The history of the Toccata & Fugue in D minor. Why’s this such a big deal? There’s no manuscript. Disney’s Fantasia.

00:26:09 – My pinned comment. Are they lying? Evolution vs. creation.

00:36:21 – How do I respond to all this? Your mom jokes. Credibility.

00:39:17 – The time a hater quoted MY OWN TEACHER to prove me wrong. Urtext editions. Was Glenn Gould a troll?

00:49:17 – Why I used “your mom” jokes to reply to comments. Are mom jokes insults? Using offense as a weapon.

00:53:24 – Doubling down. Agreeing with the haters. Making fun of yourself first. Taking the wind out of their sails. Trying all the different approaches.

00:55:43 – My videos are for adults, not kids. But I’m not making this an 18+ channel to protect the kids. Sorry.

00:56:26 – Is it wrong to delete comments? It rubs them the wrong way. Free speech. But you’re all guests at my party. Why I hate inclusivity. Facebook groups that have rules about respecting everyone’s opinions are a mess.

01:01:01 – They can make their own videos and talk about anything they want. Even trash-talking me.

01:08:23 – Why I’m not going to prove I have a master’s degree. Negotiating with terrorists. I’m not good at piano but I’m better than all of you.

01:09:50 – They don’t like my personality. How I don’t conform. They’re envious. They want respect and view it as a scarce resource.These people hate children. Generational trauma.

01:13:20 – “Bro pinned his own comment!”, “Bro wrote a WHOLE ESSAY!”. Artists vs. graffiti vandals. “You’re just doing it for views!”

01:15:47 – Am I a “troll”? There are two kinds of trolls. The word is ambiguous. I’m a “classical troll.” Trolls vs. haters. “Piece” vs. “song”. HTML the “programming language”. I’m going to keep trying to rock the boat. Paris Hilton. Howard Stern. Amy’s Baking Company.

About the Author

Piano lessons that respect WHY we do music at all. Piano lessons for adults who were bullied as kids. Piano for meditators.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
>